Comparisons

CoolerTracker vs Excel: tracking your MTT results without typing

A spreadsheet is the most common way to track tournament results: free, flexible and yours. The problem is volume. Logging 20 or 30 MTTs a session gets old fast, and even if you do it perfectly, the sheet only knows how much you won, not why.

6 min•October 29, 2026•CoolerTracker Team

TL;DR

Excel wins on flexibility and price: you can log anything, including live tournaments and cash, from any device. CoolerTracker wins on time and depth: it reads your online tournaments from your PokerTracker 4 database, fills in your daily, weekly and monthly summary on its own and, because it sees the hands, separates luck (coolers, bad beats, flips) from results. If you play online MTTs on Windows with PT4, you can stop typing.

Start the 7-day trial

If your hands are already in PT4, your history shows up without copying anything. 7 days free, no card.

At a glance

What each option gives you for tracking tournament results.

AspectCoolerTrackerExcel (manual sheet)
How data gets inAutomatically from your PT4 databaseBy hand, one tournament at a time
Time per sessionNone: the daily view refreshes on its own every 10 secondsA few minutes per session, more at high volume
ROI, ABI, net result, re-entriesCalculated for youWith formulas you build and maintain
Separating luck from resultsEstimated Luck Score, coolers, bad beats and flipsNo: the sheet can't see your hands
Daily, weekly and monthly viewsBuilt in, with a calendarWith pivot tables or your own tabs
What you can trackOnline tournaments imported into PT4Anything: live, cash, staking, expenses
DevicesWindows 10/11 PCAny (Windows, Mac, mobile, web)
Data exportNot yet (CSV/PDF on the roadmap)Yes, CSV and other formats
ErrorsNo typos; relies on PT4 importing correctlyTypos and broken formulas
Price$99 one-time (requires PT4)Free or included with Microsoft 365

We compare against a typical results spreadsheet. A heavily customized sheet can do more, but it still depends on you entering the data by hand.

The differences in detail

What you gain and what you give up when you drop the sheet.

Excel's real cost is your time

Logging name, site, buy-in, re-entries, finish, prize and bounties for each tournament is fine with 5 tournaments. With 25 a session, several times a week, it's hours a month and a constant source of mistakes. CoolerTracker reads the same fields from your PT4 database and shows them in the daily view without you typing anything.

What a spreadsheet can never see

Excel only knows each tournament's final result. It doesn't know you got it in with KK against AA, lost three flips in a row or got outdrawn as an 80/20 favorite on the bubble. CoolerTracker analyzes the hands in each tournament, labels coolers, bad beats and flips, and calculates an estimated Luck Score. It's the difference between "a −10 buy-in week" and "a −10 buy-in week with a very low Luck Score and four coolers".

Where Excel is still better

If you play live, mix cash and tournaments, track staking with several backers or need to export data for your accounting, a spreadsheet is more flexible. CoolerTracker only covers the online tournaments you have in PT4 and doesn't export to CSV or PDF yet. Plenty of players will use both: CoolerTracker for online day-to-day and a small sheet for everything else.

Your history, without redoing anything

You don't import your spreadsheet. If your hand histories are already in PT4, CoolerTracker shows your past days, weeks and months as soon as you connect it, with the same detail as today's session. For the first few days you can cross-check it against your sheet for peace of mind.

Which one fits you?

Switch to CoolerTracker if…

  • You play online MTTs at volume and already use PT4 on Windows.
  • Copying results into your sheet eats your time, or you forget to do it.
  • You want to know whether a downswing is variance or a leak.
  • You'd like to share your day or your year on Discord without taking screenshots.

Stick with Excel if…

  • You mostly play live or cash games.
  • You don't use PT4 (or you use HM3, which isn't supported yet).
  • You play on a Mac or on your phone.
  • You need to export data or keep custom staking accounts.

Pricing: free vs $99 once

An Excel or Google Sheets spreadsheet costs nothing. CoolerTracker costs $99 one-time, with no subscription, and you need PokerTracker 4, which is paid separately.

The math worth doing is about time: if you spend 10 minutes a session copying tournaments into your sheet, that's several hours a month. The 7-day free trial, with no card, is enough to see whether you get that time back and whether the Luck Score changes how you review.

Moving from Excel to CoolerTracker

No need to migrate your sheet: the data comes from PT4.

  1. 1

    Make sure PT4 is importing hand histories from the sites you play on.

  2. 2

    Install CoolerTracker from the Microsoft Store, sign in with Google and connect your PT4 database.

  3. 3

    Pick your currency and language and select your player account(s).

  4. 4

    Open last month in the monthly view and compare the numbers with your sheet.

From then on, play as usual: the daily view fills itself in. If you'd rather look around before connecting anything, demo mode comes with sample data.

FAQ

Isn't a poker tournament Excel template good enough?

Yes, if you play low volume or live. For online MTTs with PT4, a template makes you type every tournament and can't measure luck, because it can't see your hands.

Can I import my spreadsheet into CoolerTracker?

You don't need to, and for now you can't. CoolerTracker reads your history straight from PT4, so whatever is imported there shows up on its own.

Does it work for live tournaments?

No. It needs hand histories in PT4, so it covers online tournaments.

Can I export my results to Excel?

Not yet. CSV and PDF export is on the roadmap.

Do I need PokerTracker 4?

Yes. CoolerTracker connects to your PT4 database. Hold'em Manager 3 support is on the roadmap.

How much does it cost and how do I try it?

7 days free with no card. After that, $99 one-time: a lifetime license, no subscription.

Stop copying tournaments by hand

Connect PT4 and let your session, week and month fill themselves in, with luck measured in every tournament. 7 days free, no card.